November 14 2007

VOLVO CALAMITY
Dear Friends,
When this year began, Dorothy and I were a three-car family. We are ending it as a one-car family. You already know what happened to our mini-motor home. But you haven't yet heard the sad and still-unfinished story of how we lost our Volvo station wagon. I'm going to tell you about it in some detail, not only because the tale may have some cautionary value, but also because your input may help us decide how to proceed from here on. But in order to make a fair judgment, you have to know all the relevant facts.

[In case you don't have time to read all the following, here is a brief summary of what happened: After being checked out by a Volvo specialist to prepare it for a specific short trip, the car not only proved unable to complete the trip, but was declared a total loss, and had to be abandoned. Legal action is being considered.]

The car was a 1989 4D 4-Cylinder Turbo Wagon. Dorothy had bought it almost new from a Volvo dealer in November 1988. She maintained it fairly well, and it was primarily her car until December 2004 when she bought a new BMW. She couldn't bear to part with the Volvo altogether, so it then became "mine." As you probably know, I drive very little, and mostly the car just sat parked in the street (since we had no driveway space for it). However, I began to take a little more interest in it after deciding in May of this year to dispose of the motor home.

I had been wanting to take some kind of a journey out of town, and in June an opportunity arose for me to do so, and to help a friend at the same time. My friend Steve needed to have a large load of books (13 boxes) transported from Santa Barbara to a book dealer in the Sacramento area -- a distance of about 380 miles. I offered to do the job, using our Volvo. I first confirmed that the weight of the load was well within the specified capacity of the vehicle. Then, although the car seemed to be running well, I wanted to have it thoroughly checked out, to make sure it was in good condition for this trip. The odometer showed some 127,000 miles (which isn't that much for a Volvo) but the odometer itself seemed to be malfunctioning, and was one of the things I wanted to have checked.

Apart from the official dealership, there are three repair places in Santa Barbara which specialize in Volvos. We had tried them all at various times, and were currently favoring Dave Scholl Automotive, which seems to be a small family operation. (Dave uses his little girl in his commercials to tell you what good care her Daddy will take of your car.) So I took the car to Dave Scholl and told him exactly about the planned journey with the planned load, and made it plain that my specific purpose in coming to him was to have the car well prepared for this mission. (He actually wrote "Check for trip" on the repair invoice.)

Dave Scholl kept the car in his shop for 2 days, during which he called me several times and made various recommendations. I am no mechanic. I felt I had to trust him, and I simply agreed to everything he suggested. The final bill, which I paid on June 22, came to nearly a thousand dollars -- actually, $944.53. This seemed a lot, considering that, apart from the odometer, I had had no problem with the car - but at least I could now feel confident about making the proposed trip.

Here is a breakdown of what I was charged:

LABOR:

Replace tailpipe 27
Replace water pump 135
Clean throttle body & Idle Control valve 90
Resurface all brake rotors 180
Recharge Air Conditioner 45
Fuel gauge -- R& R instrument cluster - Repair power to gauge 90
Repair Vent Control Valve 45
Change oil 20
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOTAL LABOR $632
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

PARTS:

1 Tailpipe 56.86
1 Oil Filter 8.56
4 qts Oil 10.00
1 Water Pump 93.63
1 Coolant 12.00
Freon 100.00
2 ft. Silicon Vacuum Hose 9.00
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TOTAL PARTS $290.05
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TAX 22.48
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
GRAND TOTAL $ 944.53
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(Concerning the odometer, which I was sure had been faulty, and which I very much wanted to have working properly for this trip, Dave Scholl wrote on the invoice "Odometer -- No Problem Found.")

After paying the bill, I drove the car home, and didn't use it again until setting out for Sacramento with the books on June 26. I had no problem on that drive, EXCEPT that, very annoyingly, the odometer completely froze up and was useless. I delivered the books, and stayed overnight in the area.

The next day, June 27, at about 2 p.m., I was on the 80 Freeway, about to drive west out of Sacramento. It was a hot day, and I had just turned on the air conditioner for the first time since leaving Santa Barbara. The motor began to make a rattling sound, and very shortly afterwards I could smell burning, and saw that dark smoke was coming out of the exhaust. I managed to get onto an off-ramp, but couldn't even park properly before the motor died completely, and wouldn't start again.

Eventually I got hauled to Turner Volvo in Sacramento, which was the nearest Volvo dealership. Their diagnosis, which I received the following day, was that the engine was irreparably damaged, and would need to be replaced. They told me that this would probably cost more than the car was worth.

Here is the official Turner Volvo diagnosis:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Inspected and found internal engine damage. No coolant in system. Engine oil very dark and burnt smelling. #1 cylinder 90 lbs, #2 65, #3 0, and #4 95 lbs. Appears engine got very hot, melting sensors at intake and timing cover. Recommend engine replacement."
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Since the car had thus been given a virtual death sentence, I had no choice but to abandon it. I signed over the title to Omar Ramirez, one of the Turner Volvo mechanics (not the one who had done the diagnosis) who told me he planned to put in another engine, on his own time, and then sell the car.

I had to rent a car from Hertz to get home to Santa Barbara. In the more than 4 months since then, I have been trying to make some sort of settlement with Dave Scholl, so far completely without success. I was (and still am) too upset to approach him in person - and besides thought it best, for legal purposes, to have everything in writing. I first wrote him on July 4, with an account of the calamity. I didn't specifically blame him, but I felt it only fair that he, as a businessperson who must stand behind his work, should accept at least some of the responsibility. So I proposed what I thought was a reasonable settlement. I listed my principal costs as follows:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"Blue Book" value of the car $3000.00
2 hotel nights in Sacramento during diagnosis 246.86
Hertz rental car 225.91
Original Dave Scholl bill 944.53

TOTAL $4417.30
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I proposed a settlement in which he would pay just half this amount, or $2,208.65

Dave Scholl never even responded to this offer. When I repeated it on September 22, his only response was to tell me that the matter had been turned over to his insurance company.

In the meantime, however, the key piece of evidence in the case had ceased to exist. Omar Ramirez in Sacramento had come to the conclusion that it wouldn't after all be worth his while to rehabilitate the car I had given him, and had decided instead to junk it. Before doing so, however, in response to my fervent pleas, he did perform some kind of inspection to try to determine just what had caused the car to break down. He refused to put his findings in writing (not wanting, he told me, to be involved in any legal action) but he did speak separately to Dave Scholl, to me, and subsequently to a claims investigator from Dave Scholl's insurance company, Allied Insurance. Apparently all he could say was that there had been a failure in the radiator, but he could not give any specific cause.

While waiting to hear from Allied Insurance, I did accept an offer from my friend Sol to call Dave and try to mediate this dispute. According to Sol's report, Dave would not accept any responsibility whatsoever. He said that in a 17 year old car it would not be unusual for some weak spot to develop in the radiator leading to a catastrophic leak. Apparently he felt it was simply an unfortunate co-incidence that this should have happened just after his presumably thorough checking-out of the vehicle.

But I also consulted my friend Bob who, though not a professional mechanic, has owned ten Volvos which he works on and fixes up himself. He knows, and apparently respects, Dave Scholl. But he also said that "any time the cooling system is opened, a small leak can occur later due to a variety of reasons." He seemed to leave open the possibility that some mistake might have been made, such as insufficiently tightening the hose clamps, or putting in an incorrect amount of coolant.

It was not until November 5 that I received definite word from Allied Insurance. After investigating my claim, they had decided to deny it, concluding that their client Dave Scholl "was neither negligent nor legally liable."

That means that I now have two options, apart from dropping the whole matter. One is to seek redress from the California State Bureau of Automotive Repair. This agency has no power to collect money or levy fines, and apparently attempts mainly to settle disputes by mediation. Its nearest mediation office is 100 miles away. I could however at least fill in the 4-page "Consumer On-line Complaint Form" on its website and see what happens. But judging from Dave Scholl's stonewall attitude thus far, I fear that that whole process might just be another exercise in futility.

The other, and ultimate, alternative, of course, is to go to court -- which in this case would be our local Small Claims Court, which at least is actually located here in Santa Barbara, and where, in matters such as this, one may claim amounts up to $7500. As you may know, no lawyers appear in Small Claims Court. The parties have to represent themselves. One may of course consult a lawyer beforehand - but I have not yet done so.

If I do choose to go this legal route, I will naturally have to hope for a sympathetic judge - but the question will still be, just what law has Dave Scholl broken? I am about as much of a lawyer as I am a mechanic. But, from what I can see at this point my best approach would be to allege breach of contract. The "Repair Invoice" which I was required to sign actually contains, among the very small print, the words "In the event legal action is necessary to enforce this contract…" Well, if it is a contract, what are Dave Scholl's obligations under it? The only clue is a rather cryptic paragraph which is printed on the other side of the sheet. Since this text may prove legally crucial, I feel I have to give it to you here in full:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"A buyer of this product in California has the right to have this product serviced or repaired during the warranty period. The warranty period will be extended for the number of whole days that the product has been out of the buyer's hands for warranty repairs. If a defect exists within the warranty period, the warranty will not expire until the defect has been fixed. The warranty period will also be extended if the warranty repairs have not been performed due to delays caused by circumstances beyond the control of the buyer, or if the warranty repairs did not remedy the defect and the buyer notifies the manufacturer or seller of the failure of the repairs within 60 days after they were completed. If, after a reasonable number of attempts, the defect has not been fixed, the buyer may return this product for a replacement or a refund subject, in either case, to deduction of a reasonable charge for usage. This time extension does not affect the protections or remedies the buyer has under other laws."
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't know the source of this passage, and am not clear just why it appears on the back of Dave Scholl's "Repair Invoice." There is no explanation anywhere on the form of the "warranty" or the "warranty period" which are referred to. But the general message does seem to be that "if a defect exists," that defect will be fixed. The trouble in the present case, however, is that, through no fault of mine, the putative "defect" caused the loss of the entire vehicle, which therefore cannot be returned for repair. That is why a wise Small Claims judge may be only person who can unravel this knot and give Dorothy and me the fair settlement we seek.

I might also point out that Dave Scholl knew I would be heading into hot weather - that apparently was why he chose to do all that expensive work on the air conditioning system - so one might expect him to have been equally concerned about the radiator which he himself now disparages as having been old enough to blow at any time. But he never said a word about it to me. Also, the fact that he was so wrong about the odometer certainly shows that he is capable of making mistakes. So how can anybody be sure that he didn't make some key mistake with regard to my vehicle's cooling system? ##

HOME